06-02-2020 - AGENDA ITEM 08 PUBLIC HEARING - CONSIDERATION OF ASSESSMENTS FOR FISCAL YEAR 2020-21 FOR LANDSCAPE MAINTENANCE DISTRICT NO. 4AGENDA ITEM NO.8
xft
AGENDA STAFF REPORT
City of West Covina I Office of the City Manager
DATE: June 2, 2020
TO: Mayor and City Council
FROM: David Carmany
City Manager
SUBJECT: PUBLIC HEARING - CONSIDERATION OF ASSESSMENTS FOR FISCAL YEAR 2020-21
FOR LANDSCAPE MAINTENANCE DISTRICT NO.4
RECOMMENDATION:
It is recommended that the City Council adopt the following resolution:
RESOLUTION NO.2020-49 — A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF WEST
COVINA, CALIFORNIA, APPROVING THE ENGINEER'S REPORT AND CONFIRMING A DIAGRAM
AND ASSESSMENT FOR FISCAL YEAR 2020-21 FOR LANDSCAPE MAINTENANCE DISTRICT NO.4
BACKGROUND:
The Landscaping and Lighting Act of 1972 (Streets & Highways Code Section 22500 et seq.) (the "Act") sets forth
requirements for annual proceedings for a Landscape Maintenance District (LMD). A LMD is not a separate entity
of the City. It is a financing vehicle utilized when the development of a neighborhood in the community is
identified to specially benefit by certain improvements, such as parks, playgrounds, landscapes, sidewalks, trees,
etc. Due to this special benefit, landowners in the identified area are assessed to pay the costs of the construction
and/or ongoing maintenance of such improvements.
Each LMD is created through formation proceedings (also known as a vote of the affected property owners)
pursuant to the Act. This usually occurs at the time a residential or commercial project is first developed. The Act
allows a local agency (such as the City of West Covina) to levy an annual assessment for the maintenance of the
community improvements, based on special benefit directly or indirectly, to the property owners within the LMD.
Annual assessments are paid as part of a line -item on individual property tax bills.
This report concerns Landscape Maintenance District No. 4 ("LMD4" or the "District"). LMD4 was established in
1975. This District is located in the southeasterly part of the City. The assessments collected are used to maintain
landscaping, irrigation, hardscape (e.g. sidewalks, walls, etc.), and area lighting on 130 acres of public open space
within the boundaries of the district. To encourage innovative housing types and neighborhood designs and to
preserve the ridgelines in the San Jose Hills, this area was originally developed with relatively narrow street
rights -of -way and small lot sizes. The resulting surplus land was converted to landscaped slope areas and park like
"green belt" areas containing walkways, landscaping, and lighting.
W W I LLDAN
determination of which services and activities shall be provided based on available
revenues.
Part IV
Boundary Map: A diagram showing the boundaries of the District is provided in this
Report and includes all parcels determined to receive special benefits from the
improvements. Parcel identification, the lines and dimensions of each lot, parcel and
subdivision of land within the District are shown on the Los Angeles County Assessor's
Parcel Maps, and shall include any subsequent lot line adjustments or parcel changes
therein. Reference is hereby made to the Los Angeles County Assessor's Parcel Maps
for a detailed description of the lines and dimensions of each lot and parcel of land
within the District. A diagram showing the overall boundaries of the District is on file
with the City Clerk and the Office of the City Engineer, and by reference is made part
of this Report.
Part V
Assessment Roll: A listing of the assessment amount associated with each parcel
within the District. The assessments presented herein are unchanged from the
previous FY.
PROPOSITION 218 COMPLIANCE
On November 5, 1996, California voters approved Proposition 218 ("Prop 218"). This
Proposition amended the California Constitution and was the latest in a series of
initiatives reducing the revenue -raising discretion of California local governments. The
provisions of the Proposition, now California Constitution Articles XI11 C and XIII D, can
be summarized in four general areas:
1. Strengthens the general and special tax provisions of Proposition 13 and
Proposition 62.
2. Extends the initiative process to all local taxes, assessments, fees, and charges.
3. Adds substantive and procedural requirements to assessments.
4. Adds substantive and procedural requirements to property -related fees and
charges.
Prop 218 required that beginning July 1, 1997, all new and existing assessments (with
some exceptions) must conform to new substantive and procedural requirements.
However, certain assessments are exempted from these requirements until they are
increased.
Generally, these exemptions include:
2020/2021 City of West Covina - Landscape Maintenance District No. 4 Page 3
W W I LLDAN
(a) Assessments used exclusively to fund sidewalks, streets, sewers, water, flood
control, drainage systems, or vector control.
(b) Assessments imposed pursuant to a petition signed by the persons owning all
of the parcels subject to the assessment at the time the assessment is initially
imposed.
(c) Assessments used exclusively for bond repayments, the cessation of which
would violate the Contract Impairment Clause of the U.S. Constitution.
(d) Assessments previously approved by a majority of voters.
Since the District and the related assessments were established in 1975 at the request
of the owner of the property, the initial District assessments were not required to
conform with the Article XIIID substantive and procedural requirements. The maximum
assessment rate for the District at the time of the passage of Prop 218 was $464.00
previously approved by the City Council in FY 1989-90. Any subsequent increases in
the assessments above the maximum rate previously approved by City Council prior
to November 5, 1996 will be subject to the procedures and approval process of Section
4 of Article XIIID of the California Constitution.
2020/2021 City of West Covina - Landscape Maintenance District No. 4 Page 4
WILLDAN
/, PLANS AND SPECIFICATIONS
A. ZONES OF BENEFIT
For FY 2020/2021, the parcels, lots, subdivisions and developments within the District
are identified and grouped into nine (9) zones of benefit referred to as "Zones". Each
Zone reflects the landscape improvements associated with the development of
properties in that Zone, in order to fairly and equitably apportion the net cost of
providing those improvements to the properties that receive special benefits from the
service and activities associated with those improvements. Most of the parcels in the
District are identified as single-family and multi -family residential properties. All
parcels receive special benefits from the improvements because of the increased
desirability of a parcel that is located in an area with landscaping, and open space
areas. Public agency parcels within the District will not be used for residential
occupancies or commercial/industrial workplaces, and therefore, do not receive
special benefit and will not be assessed. The assessments proposed to be levied on
each property do not exceed the reasonable cost of proportional special benefit
conferred on each property from the funded improvements.
The following is a brief description of the District Zones:
Zone A1:
Parcels in this zone are commercial properties, which are located at the intersections
of major arterial roadways. These parcels are benefited by the District improvements
to a lesser degree due to their proximity to the open space areas. Nonetheless, the
parcels are benefited by aesthetically pleasing landscaping and open space areas
which enhance the desirability of living in the District, because its promotion of evening
business and industry vitality, and contribution to a positive nighttime visual image.
Zone A2:
Parcels in this zone are condominium type homes with open space areas located
along the fringes of the zone. Due to the nature and higher density of the parcels and
the higher intensity of the property use, the parcels derive benefits such as providing
a more peaceful and relaxed lifestyle due to the surrounding open space areas.
Zone A3:
Parcels in this zone are made up of condominiums and apartment complexes with
smaller areas of open space within the zone. Due to the denser housing within this
zone, Zone A3 is distinctly benefited by the interspersed open space areas within the
zone. Although open space areas are smaller than in other zones, the incorporation
of such areas into Zone A3's higher -intensity property uses peculiarly benefits Zone
A3's parcels by providing aesthetically pleasing landscaping and enhancing the
desirability of living in Zone A3.
2020/2021 City of West Covina - Landscape Maintenance District No. 4 Page 5
W W I LLDAN
Zone A4:
Parcels in this zone are condominium type homes. The open space areas are in close
proximity to the condominiums in this zone, thus providing the zone's parcels with
benefits such as the enhancement of quality of life within the community characterized
by openness, landscape and natural vistas, wildlife and relaxed, peaceful living.
Zone A5:
Parcels in this zone are made up of detached single-family homes with large open
space areas in close proximity. Zone A5 parcels derive a benefit particular to their
zone, based on the significant size and proximity of the open space areas to the
parcels. The large open spaces in the vicinity of the parcels contribute to lower
housing density due to the dedication of acreage for landscaping and natural areas,
which thereby reduce the number of buildable parcels.
Zone A6:
Parcels in this zone are made up of detached single-family homes with open space
areas located along the fringes of the zone. Having the open space areas along the
perimeter of the zone is advantageous to the parcels within Zone A6 due to the open
space areas' positive results on the parcels, such as attracting natural flora and fauna,
providing a more peaceful and relaxed lifestyle.
Zone A7:
Parcels in this zone are made up of detached single-family homes. The open space
areas are in close proximity to the single-family homes. These open space areas are
connected with paseos that include concrete walkways and lights. These paseos
provide for safe pedestrian travel within the zone and into adjacent Zone A9.
Zone A8:
Parcels in this zone are made up of four-plexes with open space areas located along
the fringes of the zone that provide a barrier from the major arterial roadway. The
strategic location of open space areas at the fringe create an aesthetically pleasing
yet practical perimeter around the zone, which provides a more peaceful and relaxed
lifestyle by attracting natural flora and fauna to Zone A8 parcels which, because of the
close proximity to major arterial roadways, would not otherwise receive such benefit.
Moreover, the higher -intensity property use receives a significant benefit from the
natural vistas and landscaping provided by the open space areas.
2020/2021 City of West Covina - Landscape Maintenance District No. 4 Page 6
W W I LLDAN
Zone A9:
Parcels in this zone are made up of duplexes. The open space areas are in close
proximity to the duplexes and are connected by paseos. The paseos are improved
with concrete walkways and lights. These paseos provide for safe pedestrian travel
within the zone and into adjacent Zone A7, and promote social interaction.
DESCRIPTION OF WORK
The existing facilities to be maintained and serviced include public open space area,
lighting, parkway, and manufactured slopes and appurtenant facilities. There are
approximately 130 acres of open space within the District.
The District will fund the costs in connection with the district maintenance and
servicing including, but not limited to, personnel, electrical energy, water, materials,
contracting services, and other expenses necessary for the satisfactory operation of
these facilities. The facilities and improvements which have been constructed within
the District and which will be maintained and serviced are described as follows:
Landscaping and Appurtenant Facilities
Facilities include but are not limited to: landscaping, planting, shrubbery, trees,
irrigation system, hardscape, fixtures, sidewalk maintenance resulting from
landscape growth and appurtenant facilities, in public right-of-way, parkways,
and dedicated easements within the boundaries of said District.
Lighting and Appurtenant Facilities
Facilities include but are not limited to: poles, fixtures, bulbs, conduits,
conductors, equipment including guys, anchors, posts and pedestals, metering
devices and appurtenant facilities as required to provide lighting in the public
right-of-way and dedicated easements within the boundaries of said District.
"Maintenance" means, as defined in the 1972 Act, the furnishing of services and
materials for the ordinary and usual operation, maintenance and servicing of the
landscaping, public lighting facilities and appurtenant facilities, including repair,
removal or replacement of all or part of any of the landscaping, public lighting facilities
or appurtenant facilities; providing for the life, growth, health, and beauty of the
landscaping, including cultivation, irrigation, trimming, spraying, fertilizing and treating
for disease or injury; the removal of trimmings, rubbish, debris and other solid waste;
and the cleaning, sandblasting and painting of walls and other improvements to
remove or cover graffiti.
"Servicing" means the furnishing of water for the irrigation of landscaping and the
maintenance of any of the public lighting facilities and furnishing of electrical energy
for the public lighting facilities or for the lighting or operation of landscaping or
appurtenant facilities.
2020/2021 City of West Covina - Landscape Maintenance District No. 4 Page 7
W W I LLDAN
C. IMPROVEMENTS AUTHORIZED BY THE 1972 ACT
As applicable or may be applicable to this proposed District, the 1972 Act defines
improvements to mean one or any combination of the following:
• The installation or planting of landscaping.
• The installation or construction of statuary, fountains, and other ornamental
structures and facilities.
• The installation or construction of public lighting facilities.
• The installation or construction of any facilities which are appurtenant to any of
the foregoing or which are necessary or convenient for the maintenance or
servicing thereof, including, but not limited to, grading, clearing, removal of
debris, the installation or construction of curbs, gutters, walls, sidewalks, or
paving, or water, irrigation, drainage, or electrical facilities.
• The maintenance or servicing, or both, of any of the foregoing.
• The acquisition of any existing improvement otherwise authorized pursuant to
this section.
Incidental expenses associated with the improvements including, but not limited to:
• The cost of preparation of the report, including plans, specifications, estimates,
diagram, and assessment;
• The costs of printing, advertising, and the publishing, posting and mailing of
notices;
• Compensation payable to the County for collection of assessments;
• Compensation of any engineer or attorney employed to render services;
• Any other expenses incidental to the construction, installation, or maintenance
and servicing of the improvements;
• Any expenses incidental to the issuance of bonds or notes pursuant to Section
22662.5.
• Costs associated with any elections held for the approval of a new or increased
assessment.
2020/2021 City of West Covina - Landscape Maintenance District No. 4 Page 8
W W I LLDAN
DESCRIPTION OF IMPROVEMENTS AND SERVICES
The District is located in the southeasterly part of the City of West Covina. To
encourage innovative housing types and neighborhood designs, and to preserve the
ridgelines of the San Jose Hills, this area was developed with relatively narrow street
right-of-way's and small lot sizes. The resulting surplus of land was converted to
landscaped slope areas and park -like "green belt" areas containing walkways,
landscaping, and lighting.
The detailed plans and specifications of the District improvements are on file in the
office of the City Public Works Department and by reference are made part of this
Report.
Ongoing and Completed Capital Improvement Projects:
FY 2020/21, improvements included:
• There are currently no ongoing and completed capital improvement projects
for FY 2020/2021.
FY 2019/20, improvements included:
• Drought tolerant landscaping and water -wise irrigation improvements
• Basic maintenance and repair of pathways, electrical equipment, and
irrigation system
Total Cost of Improvements: $188,000
2020/2021 City of West Covina - Landscape Maintenance District No. 4 Page 9
W W I LLDAN
A METHOD OF APPORTIONMENT
The 1972 Act permits the establishment of assessment districts by agencies for the
purpose of providing certain public improvements which include the construction,
maintenance, and servicing of public lights, landscaping and appurtenant facilities.
The 1972 Act further requires that the cost of these improvements be levied according
to benefit rather than assessed value:
"The net amount to be assessed upon lands within an assessment district may be
apportioned by any formula or method which fairly distributes the net amount among all
assessable lots or parcels in proportion to the estimated benefits to be received by each
such lot or parcel from the improvements."
Because assessments are levied on the basis of benefit, they are not a tax, and,
therefore, are not governed by Article XI IA of the California Constitution.
Section 22574 of the 1972 Act permits the designation of zones of benefits within any
individual assessment district if "by reason of variation in the nature, location, and extent
of the improvements, the various areas will receive different degrees of benefit from the
improvements." Thus, the 1972 Act requires the levy of a true "assessment" rather than
a "special tax."
The 1972 Act also permits certain parcels to be exempt from assessment. Excluded from
these assessments are areas of all publicly owned property such as: public streets,
public avenues, public lanes, public roads, public drives, public courts, public alleys, all
public easements, and right-of-way's, all public parks, public greenbelts and parkways,
and all public property being used for public purposes. However, per Proposition 218,
any publicly owned property that benefits from District improvements shall be assessed
its proportional share of District costs.
The formula used for calculating assessments in this District reflects the composition
of the parcels, and the improvements and services provided in order to fairly apportion
the costs based on estimated benefit to each parcel.
A. BENEFIT ANALYSIS
All parcels in the District derive benefit from the open space maintenance. The intent
of this Report is to establish a methodology that fairly distributes the cost of the system
in relation to the benefit received.
The assessment ratio for all properties is based on dwelling units. Each single-family
residential parcel, condominium complex, apartment, duplex, multi -family residential,
and other developed land, is assessed per dwelling unit. This pro -ration accounts for
an adjustment for street right-of-way's and public easements.
2020/2021 City of West Covina - Landscape Maintenance District No. 4 Page 10
W W I LLDAN
ASSESSMENT METHODOLOGY
The methods of apportionment utilized for the District calculates the receipt of special
benefit from the respective improvements based on the actual or proposed land use
of the parcels. The special benefit received by each lot or parcel is equated to the
overall land use of the parcel based on the parcel's actual land use or proposed
planned development and is reliant upon the special benefit received from the
improvements within the District.
To identify and determine the special benefit to be received by each parcel, it is
necessary to consider the entire scope of the improvements. The costs associated
with the improvements shall be fairly distributed among the parcels based upon the
special benefit received by each parcel. Additionally, in compliance with Section 4 of
Article XIIID, each parcel's assessment may not exceed the reasonable cost of the
proportional special benefit conferred to that parcel. The benefit formula used to
determine the assessment obligation is therefore based upon both the improvements
that benefit the parcels of the District as well as the proposed land use of each property
as compared to other parcels that benefit from those specific improvements.
The assessment methodology and assessment rates proposed for FY 2020/2021
determined that all parcels receive special benefit for the landscape and lighting
maintenance. In order to continue to provide the current level of maintenance services,
the budget is proposed to be maintained at the FY 2019-20 level. Therefore, the
assessment rates for the FY 2020/2021 are not proposed to be increased.
The District was established in 1975 prior to Proposition 218 requirements, and the
assessment for all properties is based on dwelling units. Each single-family residential
parcel, condominium complex, apartment, duplex, multi -family residential, and other
developed land, is assessed per dwelling unit. The land -use classification for each
parcel is based on the Los Angeles County Auditor/Controller's Assessment Roll.
The specific percent budget allocations, which were previously established for each
zone, will not be increased in FY 2020/2021. To calculate the Assessment Rates, the
budget for each zone is divided by the total number of Equivalent Dwelling Units
("EDU") in the zone.
2020/2021 City of West Covina - Landscape Maintenance District No. 4 Page 11
W W I LLDAN
The following table summarizes the different assessment rates for the different zone
classifications and compares the proposed assessment with the prior year's
assessment.
City of West Covina
Landscape and Maintenance District No. 4
FY 2020/2021 Preliminary Assessment Summary and Comparison
Al
2%
30
451
$49.16
$49.16
$22,171.16
A2
2%
218
319
$77.89
$77.89
24,846.91
A3
13%
326
2,651
$49.33
$49.33
130,773.83
A4
11%
498
497
$232.48
$232.48
115,542.56
A5
4%
157
157
$260.98
$260.98
40,973.86
A6
7%
246
246
$289.99
$289.99
71,337.54
A7
52%
1,549
1,548
$348.02
$348.02
538,734.96
A8
5%
118
117
$386.66
$386.66
45,239.22
A9
4%
88
88
$464.00
$464.00
40,832.00
100%
3,230
6,074
- 0-
*Totals may not foot due to rounding
1-]4OI=IyIII iXd0l=9I*CI =1.lf
Al Commercial Property
A2 Condos (Triangle Area, East of Azusa Ave. and north of Woodgrove Park)
A3 Condos Minimum Maintenance Benefit
A4 Condos Medium Maintenance Benefit
A5 Single Family Triangle Area (Special Area, West of Azusa Ave and north of
Amar Rd.)
A6 Single Family Medium Maintenance Benefit
A7 Single Family Maximum Maintenance Benefit
A8 Four-plex Minimum Maintenance Benefit
A9 Duplex Minimum Maintenance Benefit
2020/2021 City of West Covina - Landscape Maintenance District No. 4 Page 12
DISCUSSION:
The Act specifies the procedures for renewal of landscape maintenance districts. At its regular meeting on May 5,
2020, the City Council preliminarily approved the Engineer's Report prepared pursuant to the provisions of the Act
The City Council also adopted Resolution No. 2020-28, declaring its intention to levy and collect the assessment
for Fiscal Year 2020-21 and set June 2, 2020 as the date for the public hearing.
The preliminary approval of the Engineer's Report does not commit the City Council to adopt the proposed
assessments for LMD4. During or after the public hearing, the City Council may order changes in the
improvements, any zones within the assessment district, and the proposed diagram or the proposed assessment.
However, it cannot raise the rate that is now capped by Proposition 218. The City Council's action only becomes
final when the diagram and assessment are confirmed by resolution upon completion of the public hearing.
The next step is conducting the public hearing. Following the public hearing, the City Council may adopt a
resolution confirming the diagram and assessment levy either as proposed or as revised by the City Council. The
adoption of the resolution levies the assessment for the upcoming Fiscal Year.
The District contains lighted paseos and approximately 30 to 50-foot landscaped hillside slopes vegetated with
plants, shrubbery, and trees. The current scope of work for the operations, maintenance, and care of these areas
include 3 to 5 feet of fire clearing at the tops and toes of slopes and irrigation maintenance repairs. Increased scope
of work for the District is recommended to include the modification of the paseo lighting to LED for energy cost
savings, repair and replacement of light standards, hardscape repair and replacement of off -grade, cracked and
broken areas, tree trimming of the hillside trees on a trimming cycle, and landscape maintenance including trash
removal and clearing of the hillside plants and shrubbery. It is estimated that the budget required for the increased
lighting, hardscape, and landscaping scope is approximately double the existing District budget.
As outlined in the May 5, 2020 staff report relating to LMD4, the assessment rates have not been increased in over
15 years, which has led to reduced services and increased concerns by residents. As costs have risen, maintenance
has suffered. A full study of what a proper level of maintenance would cost and explore how to set the assessment
rate accordingly is recommended. Such a study will take several months and, if rates are to be increased, would
require a vote by the affected property owners.
Pending completion of a further analysis, this report recommends that assessment rates be maintained at their
current levels for Fiscal Year 2020-21. In order to increase the rates further, it would be necessary to comply with
the voting requirements of Article XIIID of the California Constitution. LMD4 has nine separate zones of benefit
based on property type and level of benefit with varying annual assessment rates including maximum benefit rates
of $49.16 for a Zone Al commercial property, $232.48 for a Zone A4 condo, $348.02 for a Zone A7 single family
unit, $386.66 for Zone A8 4-plex and $464.00 for a Zone A9 duplex unit.
LEGAL REVIEW:
The City Attorney's Office has reviewed the resolution and approved it as to form.
OPTIONS:
The City Council has the following options:
1. Adopt staffs recommendation to maintain the assessment rates at their current levels. The attached "I 0-Year
Fiscal Projection" (Attachment No. 3) shows rates being maintained at their current levels and the reserve
levels over the next 10 years; or
2. Reduce the assessment rates; however, LMD4's reserves will be depleted at a faster pace requiring the City's
General Fund to subsidize the District; or
3. Provide alternative direction.
Prepared by: Michael Ackerman, City Engineer
W W I LLDAN
///, ESTIMATE OF COSTS
The total estimate of costs for maintenance of the proposed improvements for FY
2020/2021, as defined under Section 22569 of the 1972 Act, are those as hereinafter
set forth. Said cost estimates include the total District costs for constructing or
installing any proposed improvements and for maintenance and servicing the existing
improvements including incidental expenses; the amount of any surplus or deficit in
the maintenance fund to be carried over from the previous year; any annual
installments to be collected over more than a single year; as well as the amount of
any contributions to be made from any other sources.
A. CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT PROJECT FUND
For FY 2020/2021, there are no capital improvement projects.
B. PROPOSED INCREASE SCOPE OF WORK AND SUMMARY OF COSTS
The City's budget for the operation and service costs detail the estimated costs and
fund balances for FY 2020/2021 as available at the time of preparation of this Report.
The 1972 Act provides that the total cost can be recovered in the assessment spread
including incidental expenses. The latter can include engineering fees, legal fees,
printing, mailing, postage, publishing, and all other related costs identified with the
District proceedings.
The 1972 Act requires that a special fund be set-up for the revenue and expenditures
of the District. Funds raised by the assessment shall be used only for the purpose as
stated herein. A contribution to the District by the City may be made to reduce
assessments, as the City Council deems appropriate. Any balance or deficit
remaining on July 18t must be carried over to the next FY.
Also located in the budget is the proposed increase in scope of maintenance work at
optimal levels. The District contains lighted paseos and approximately 30 to 50-foot
landscaped hillside slopes vegetated with plants, shrubbery, and trees. The current
scope of work for the operations, maintenance, and care of these areas include 3 to
5-feet of fire clearing at the tops and toes of slopes and irrigation maintenance repairs.
Increased scope of work for the District is recommended to include the modification
of the Paseo Lighting to LED for energy cost savings, repair and replacement of light
standards, hardscape repair and replacement of off -grade, cracked and broken areas,
tree trimming of the hillside trees on a trimming cycle, and landscape maintenance
including trash removal and clearing of the hillside plants and shrubbery. It is
estimated that the budget required for the increased lighting, hardscape, and
landscaping scope is approximately double the existing District budget.
2020/2021 City of West Covina - Landscape Maintenance District No. 4 Page 13
W WILLDAN
Existing Maintenance
Optimal Maintenance
Previous Fiscal Year Fund Balance
$2,368,866
$2,368,866
Revenues
Assessment Income (Total Balance to Levy)
$1,030,462
$1,030,452
Interest
3,541
3,541
Reimbursement from District No.2
9,000
9,000
Total Projected Revenue
$1,042,993
$1,042,993
Expenditures
Direct Maintenance
Personnel SeNces
$173,553
$347,106
Materials and Services
Maintenance Contracts
269,323
538,646
Utilities (electricity&wstar)
345,000
690,000
Maintenance Supplies
30,512
61,024
Property& Liability Insurance
11289
22,578
Administration &overhead
121,704
243,408
Total Direct Maintenance
951,381
$1,902,762
Engineering & Incidental
Personnel Services
$9,510
$19,020
NPDES
75,000
150,000
Equipment Outlay
0
0
Total Engineering & Incidental
84,510
169,020
Capital Improvement 111
$0
$0
Total Operating and Capital Budget
$1,035,891
$2,071,782
Ending Fund Balance
$2,375,968
$1,340,077
0) See Capital Project Fund Section III. A.
Note: The variance in existing and optimal maintenance is the amount needed to support the recommended increased scope of work for
Landscape Maintenance District 4. The recommended scope of work includes the modification of the Paseo Lighting to LED for energy
cost savings, repair and replacement of light standards, hardscape repair and replacement of off -grade, cracked and broken areas, tree
trimming of the hillside trees on a trimming cycle, and landscape maintenance including trash removal and clearing of the hillside plants
and shrubbery.
2020/2021 City of West Covina - Landscape Maintenance District No. 4 Page 14
WILLDAN
/V. BOUNDARY MAP
A diagram showing the exterior boundaries of the District, boundaries of any zone
within the District and the lines and dimensions of each lot or parcel of land within the
District is on file in the Office of the City Engineer and incorporated herein by
reference. The lines and dimensions shown on the Los Angeles County Assessor's
parcel maps for the current year are incorporated by reference and made part of this
Report.
2020/2021 City of West Covina - Landscape Maintenance District No. 4 Page 15
n/ WILLDAN
CITY OF WEST COVINA
LANDSCAPE MAINTENANCE DISTRICT NO, 4
2020/2021 City of West Covina - Landscape Maintenance District No. 4 Page 16
Wry W I LLDAN
V, ASSESSMENT ROLL
Parcel identification for each lot or parcel within the District shall be the parcel as
shown on the Los Angeles County Secured Roll for the year in which this Report is
prepared and reflective of the Assessor's Parcel Maps. A listing of the proposed lots
and parcels to be assessed within this District along with the assessment amounts
shall be submitted to the City Clerk, under a separate cover, and by reference is
made part of this Report.
2020/2021 City of West Covina - Landscape Maintenance District No. 4 Page 17
ATTACHMENT NO.3
West Covina Landscape Maintenance District No. 4
10 Year Fiscal Projection
Assessment Income
$1,030,452
$1,030,452
$1,030,452
$1,030,452
$1,030,452
$1,030,452
$1,030,452
$1,030,452
$1,030,452
$1,030,452
Interest (1)
3,541
4,752
4,727
4,660
4,550
4,395
4,195
3,949
3,656
3,315
Transfer In From District 2
9,000
9,000
9,000
9,000
9,000
9,000
9,000
9,000
9,000
9,000
Prior Year Balance
2,368,866
2,375,968
2,363,563
2,330,001
2,274,818
2,197,538
2,097,677
1,974,743
1,828,232
1,657,629
Total Funding
$3,411,859
$3,420,172
$3,407,742
$3,374,113
$3,318,819
$3,241,385
$3,141,325
$3,018,145
$2,871,340
$2,700,396
Maintenance Costs (2)
1,035,891
1,056,609
1,077,741
1,099,296
1,121,282
1,143,707
1,166,582
1,189,913
1,213,711
1,237,986
Capital Improvements
0
Total Cost
$1,035,891
$1,056,609
$1,077,741
$1,099,296
$1,121,282
$1,143,707
$1,166,582
$1,189,913
$1,213,711
$1,237,986
Ending Balance
$2,375,968
$2,363,563
$2,330,001
$2,274,818
$2,197,538
$2,097,677
$1,974,743
$1,828,232
$1,657,629
$1,462,410
Assessment of Highest Zone (3)
$464
$464
$464
$464
$464
$464
$464
$464
$464
$464
Notes: (1) Interest is 0.4% of one-half of the previous year ending balance.
(2) 2% increase in maintenance cost each year due to inflation.
(3) Previously approved maximum highest rate of $464, may not be increased further without vote
ATTACHMENT NO.4
RESOLUTION NO.2020-49
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF
WEST COVINA, CALIFORNIA, APPROVING THE
ENGINEER'S REPORT AND CONFIRMING A DIAGRAM
AND ASSESSMENT FOR FISCAL YEAR 2020-21 FOR
LANDSCAPE MAINTENANCE DISTRICT NO.4
WHEREAS, the City's Landscape Maintenance District No. 4 (the `District') has been
established pursuant to the Landscaping and Lighting Act of 1972 (Streets and Highways Code
Section 22500 et seq.) (the Acf) to fund the maintenance and servicing of certain public
landscaping and appurtenant facilities in the City; and
WHEREAS, in connection with the District, the City annually levies an assessment against
real property; and
WHEREAS, by its Resolution No. 2020-27, adopted May 5, 2020, the City Council
directed Willdan Financial Services, as assessment engineer (the "Engineer"), to prepare and file
a report regarding the District; and
WHEREAS, the Engineer filed said report, entitled "City of West Covina, Landscape
Maintenance District No. 4, Fiscal Year 2020/2021 Engineer's Report" (the "Report'), which is
on file and available for public inspection in the Office of the City Clerk and is incorporated herein
by reference; and
WHEREAS, by its Resolution No. 2020-28, adopted May 5, 2020, the City Council
preliminarily approved the Report, declared its intention to levy an assessment in connection with
the District for Fiscal Year 2020-21, and called a public hearing on the assessment for June 2, 2020
(the `Hearing'); and
WHEREAS, at the Hearing, which was noticed as required by law, all interested persons
were afforded the opportunity to hear and be heard and the City Council considered all oral and
written statements and all written protests made or filed by any interest person; and
WHEREAS, the City Council now desires to complete proceedings to levy the Fiscal Year
2020-21 assessment in connection with the District.
NOW, THEREFORE, THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF WEST COVINA,
CALIFORNIA DOES HEREBY RESOLVE AS FOLLOWS:
SECTION 1. The City Council hereby approves the Report as filed.
SECTION 2. The City Council hereby confirms the diagram and assessment contained in
the Report.
SECTION 3. Pursuant to Section 22631 of the Act, the adoption of this Resolution shall
constitute the levy of the assessment for Fiscal Year 2020-21.
SECTION 4. The City Clerk is directed to file the diagram and assessment, or a certified
copy thereof, with the Los Angeles County Auditor -Controller. The assessments shall be collected at
the same time and in the same manner as County taxes are collected, and all laws providing for the
collection and enforcement of County taxes shall apply to the collection and enforcement of the
assessments.
SECTION 5. The City Council finds that the levy and collection of these assessments is
statutorily exempt from CEQA pursuant to Section 15273 of the Guidelines, in that the proceeds of
the assessments are to be used for meeting operating expenses, purchasing supplies and meeting
financial reserves needs and requirements.
SECTION 6. The City Clerk shall certify to the adoption of this Resolution and shall enter
the same in the book of original resolutions and it shall become effective immediately.
APPROVED AND ADOPTED this 2nd day of June 2020.
Tony Wu, Mayor
APPROVED AS TO FORM ATTEST
Thomas P. Duarte Lisa Sherrick
City Attorney Assistant City Clerk
I, LISA SHERRICK, Assistant City Clerk of the City of West Covina, California, do
hereby certify that the foregoing Resolution No. 2020-49 was duly adopted by the City Council of
the City of West Covina, California, at a regular meeting thereof held on the 2nd day of June,
2020, by the following vote of the City Council:
AYES:
NOES:
ABSENT:
ABSTAIN:
Lisa Sherrick, CMC
Assistant City Clerk
Fiscal Impact
FISCAL IMPACT:
The Fiscal Year 2020-2021 Engineer's Report for LMD4 recommends that the assessment rates be maintained at
their current levels. The annual assessment rates for LMD4 will be maintained at $49.16 for commercial property,
$232.48 for condos, $348.02 for a single dwelling unit, $464.00 for a duplex unit, and $386.66 for a 4-plex unit.
The projected income from the recommended rates is $1,030,452. In addition, $9,000 is projected to be received
from Landscape Maintenance District No. 2 (LMD2) for costs of maintenance in an overlap area between LMD2
and LMD4. The total projected revenue is $1,042,993, including $3,541 in interest. With the $2,368,866 balance
from the previous year, the funding for Fiscal Year 2020-21 will be $2,375,968.
The preliminary operating budget for LMD4 for Fiscal Year 2020-2021 is $1,035,891, which is an increase of 2%
compared to the approved/amended budget for Fiscal Year 2019-2020. The proposed operating budget funds only
the regular landscape maintenance. Ongoing improvements such as irrigation system improvements, enhancement
to existing landscaping, tree trimming, and other extras are being eliminated to maintain the operating budget
within projected revenues from the capped assessment rates.
Attachments
Attachment No. 1 - 15 Year Rate History
Attachment No. 2 - LMD4 Engineer's Report
Attachment No. 3 - 10 Year Fiscal Projection
Attachment No. 4 - Resolution No. 2020-49
CITY COUNCIL GOALS & OBJECTIVES: Enhance City Facilities and Infrastructure
Enhance the City Image and Effectiveness
Respond to the Global COVID-19 Pandemic
ATTACHMENT NO. 1
West Covina
Landscape Maintenance District No.4
15 Rate History
2020/21
Proposed
$464.00
2019/20
$464.00
2018/19
$464.00
2017/18
$464.00
2016/17
$464.00
2015/16
$464.00
2014/15
$464.00
2013/14
$464.00
2012/13
$464.00
2011/12
$464.00
2010/11
$464.00
2009/10
$464.00
2008/09
$464.00
2007/08
$464.00
2006/07
$464.00
*MD4 has nine (9) separate zones of benefit with varying
assessment rates from $49.16 to $464.00 per assessment
unit. The zone shown in the table is for a single parcel
with a duplex and is the highest assessment per parcel.
ATTACHMENT NO. 2
City of West Covina
Landscape Maintenance
District No. 4
FISCALYEAR 2020/2021 ENGINEER'S REPORT
Intent Meeting: May 5, 2020
Public Hearing: June 2, 2020
W W I LLDAN
ENGINEER'S REPORT AFFIDAVIT
City of West Covina Landscape Maintenance District No. 4
City of West Covina,
County of Los Angeles, State of California
This Report describes the District including the improvements, budgets, parcels and
assessments to be levied for Fiscal Year 2020/2021 as they existed at the time of the
passage of the Resolution of Intention. Reference is hereby made to the Los Angeles
County Assessor's maps for a detailed description of the lines and dimensions of parcels
within the District. The undersigned respectfully submits the enclosed Report as directed
by the City Council.
Dated this 13th day of Ily , 2020.
Willdan Financial Services
Assessment Engineer
On Behalf of the City of West Covina
By: ��� x)w
01
Chonney Gano, Project Manager
District Administration Services
By:
Richard Kopecky
R. C. E. # 16742
Ir_1 im*610016P►kI=1LlkV
OVERVIEW.....................................................................................................................1
PROPOSITION 218 COMPLIANCE...............................................................................3
I.
PLANS AND SPECIFICATIONS.............................................................................5
A.
ZONES OF BENEFIT...........................................................................................5
B.
DESCRIPTION OF WORK...................................................................................7
C.
IMPROVEMENTS AUTHORIZED BY THE 1972 ACT ......................................... 8
D.
DESCRIPTION OF IMPROVEMENTS AND SERVICES.....................................9
II.
METHOD OF APPORTIONMENT.........................................................................10
A.
BENEFIT ANALYSIS.......................................................................................... 10
B.
ASSESSMENT METHODOLOGY...................................................................... 11
III.
ESTIMATE OF COSTS..........................................................................................13
A.
CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT PROJECT FUND .................................................... 13
B.
SUMMARY OF TOTAL COSTS......................................................................... 13
C.
INCREASED SCOPE OF WORK AND SUMMARY OF COSTS ........................ 13
IV.
BOUNDARY MAP.................................................................................................15
V.
ASSESSMENT ROLL............................................................................................17
* WILLDAN
OVERVIEW
The City of West Covina ("City"), annually levies and collects assessments in order to
provide and maintain facilities, improvements and services within Landscape
Maintenance District No. 4 ("District"). The District was established in 1975 pursuant
to the Landscaping and Lighting Act of 1972, Part 2 of Division 15 of the Streets and
Highways Code (" 1972 Act"). The District was created at the request of the owner of
the developments in lieu of forming a Homeowner's Association. The funds collected
are used to maintain landscaping, irrigation, hardscape, and paseo lighting on 130
acres of public open space within the boundaries of the District.
The Engineer's Report ("Report") has been prepared pursuant to Chapter 1, Article 4
and Chapter 3 of the 1972 Act, and presented to the City Council for their
consideration and approval of the proposed improvements and services to be
provided within the District and the levy and collection of annual assessments for
Fiscal Year ("FY") 2020/2021.
This Report describes the District, the improvements and the proposed assessments
to be levied against properties in connection with the benefits the properties will
receive from the maintenance and servicing of the District improvements for FY
2020/21. The annual assessments to be levied on properties within the District provide
a funding source for the continued operation and maintenance of local landscape
improvements installed in connection with the development of properties within the
District. Each FY, the City establishes the District's assessments based on an
estimate of the costs to maintain, operate and service the landscape improvements
and based upon available revenues including fund balances, City contributions and
assessment limits. The costs of the improvements and the proposed annual
assessments budgeted and assessed against properties within the District may
include: the estimated expenditures for regular annual maintenance and repairs;
incidental expenditures related to the operation and administration of the District;
deficits or surpluses from prior years; revenues from other sources; and the collection
of adequate funds for operational reserves or periodic expenditures including
installments collected for long-term improvement projects. Each parcel is assessed
proportionately for only those improvements, services and expenses for which the
parcel will receive special benefit.
The word "parcel," for the purposes of this Report, refers to an individual property
assigned its own Assessor's Parcel Number ("APN") by the Los Angeles County
("County") Assessor's Office. The County Auditor/Controller uses Assessor's Parcel
Numbers and specific Fund Numbers to identify properties to be assessed on the tax
roll for the special benefit assessments.
At a noticed annual Public Hearing, the City Council will accept all public comments
and written protests regarding the District and the annual levy of assessments. Upon
conclusion of the Public Hearing, the City Council will consider all public comments
and review the Report. The City Council may order amendments to the Report or
confirm the Report as submitted. Following final approval of the Report and
2020/2021 City of West Covina - Landscape Maintenance District No. 4 Page 1
W W I LLDAN
confirmation of the assessments the Council will, by Resolution, order the
improvements to be made and confirm the levy and collection of assessments
pursuant to the 1972 Act. The assessments as approved will be submitted to the
County Auditor/Controller to be included on the property tax roll for each parcel.
While the budgets outlined in this Report reflect the estimated costs necessary to fully
and adequately provide for the maintenance and operation of the improvements within
the District, many of these estimated costs and associated services cannot be funded
by the current assessment revenues. To fully fund the improvements, it will be
necessary to increase assessment revenues which will require the support of the
property owners for new or increased assessments through a ballot proceeding
conducted under the provisions of the California Constitution Article XIIID. Although
such proceedings are not being conducted this FY and the proposed District
assessments for FY 2020/2021 are not being increased over the assessments levied
in the prior FY, such assessment increases may be considered in the future due to
the rising costs associated with the maintenance of District improvements.
As required by the 1972 Act, this Engineer's Report describes the improvements to
be operated, maintained and serviced by the District, an estimated budget for the
District improvements, and the proposed assessments to be levied upon each
assessable lot or parcel within the District for FY 2020/2021.
This Report consists of five (5) parts:
Part I
Plans and Specifications: A general description of the District and the improvements
for which parcels are assessed. The proposed assessments as outlined in this Report
are based on the improvements that provide a special benefit to the properties within
the District. The plans and specifications contained in this Report generally describe
the nature, location and extent of the improvements.
Part II
Method of Apportionment: A description of how the proportionate amount of the
assessments is to be charged in proportion to the benefits received by each lot or
parcel within the boundaries of the District.
Part III
Estimate of Costs: An estimate of the annual costs to properly operate, maintain,
and service the landscape improvements and appurtenant facilities. This budget
includes an estimate of the maintenance costs and incidental expenses including, but
not limited to: labor, materials, equipment and administration expenses as well as the
collection of appropriate funding necessary to properly support the improvements. Not
all services and costs identified in these budgets can be supported by the current
assessment revenues and City contributions, and as such, City staff shall make the
2020/2021 City of West Covina - Landscape Maintenance District No. 4 Page 2